News Defense Verdict in Yamaha Rhino Trial

Defense Verdict in Yamaha Rhino Trial

Powersports News

On Wednesday, August 11, 2010, after a seven week trial, a San Bernardino County, California, jury found no defect and delivered another major verdict for Yamaha in a case involving the Yamaha Rhino off-road vehicle.

Jacob Daniel Lewis and Patrick Hernandez, Plaintiffs vs. Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A., Yamaha Motor Manufacturing Corporation of America and Defendant Seidner Enterprises, LLC, d.b.a. Bert’s Mega Mall.

Superior Court of California, for the County of San Bernardino, Case No. 06CC11291, Judge Gilbert G. Ochoa presiding.

Plaintiffs alleged that defects in a 2007 Rhino 660 vehicle caused their injuries in an April 16, 2007 crash that occurred when plaintiff Jacob Lewis struck two dirt berms while driving near the vehicle’s 40 mph top speed.

The vehicle became airborne and overturned, resulting in head and upper extremity injuries to Mr. Lewis and his passenger, plaintiff Patrick Hernandez. Both plaintiffs were wearing seat belts at the time of the crash; but, contrary to Yamaha’s on product warnings, neither was wearing a helmet.

Plaintiffs claimed that the Rhino lacked adequate occupant protection from head and upper extremity injuries and alleged that the vehicle was sold with defective seats and seat belts. Plaintiffs also claimed that the Rhino should have been equipped with roll bar padding and four-point harnesses rather then three-point seat belts.

Yamaha defended its design as safe and defect free and contended that plaintiffs caused their own injuries by reckless, high speed driving and by failing to wear helmets. Plaintiffs denied reckless driving and claimed that helmets would not have prevented Mr. Lewis’ brain injury.

Plaintiff Lewis sustained brain and upper arm injuries and plaintiff Hernandez sustained a shoulder injury and an alleged head injury resulting in post traumatic stress disorder.

Collectively, plaintiffs sought over $15 million in compensatory damages. Plaintiffs’ case went to verdict on a strict product liability design defect claim.

The jury’s special verdict for Yamaha rejected plaintiffs’ claim, finding that the Rhino met ordinary consumer expectations, and therefore, was not defective.

Plaintiffs’ witnesses included engineer Dr. Voyko Banjac from San Diego, California; accident reconstruction expert Stephen Plourd from San Diego, California; biomechanic Joseph Awad from San Diego, California; neuropsychologist Dr. Robert Sbordone from Irvine, California; neurologist Dr. Jeffrey Bounds from Loma Linda, California; radiologist Dr. Gary Stimac, from Seattle, Washington; vocational rehabilitation expert Dr. Roger Thrush from La Mesa, California; life care planner Elizabeth Holakiewicz, from Carlsbad, California; and, economist Vicke Wolfe, from San Diego, California.

Yamaha’s witnesses included accident reconstructionist Dr. Graeme Fowler from Phoenix, Arizona; biomechanic Dr. Harry Smith from San Antonio, Texas; seat expert Andrew Levitt from Torrance, California; seat belt engineer Mr. Eddie Cooper from Phoenix, Arizona; and, neuropsychologist Dr. Anthony Strickland from Los Angeles, California.

Plaintiffs were represented by Charles S. LiMandri and Richard Salpietra from Rancho Santa Fe, California.

Yamaha was represented by its lead counsel Robert Miller of the national product liability defense firm Bowman and Brooke in Los Angeles, California and Timothy J. Mattson of Bowman and Brooke in Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Mr. Miller and Mr. Mattson were assisted at trial by Richard Stuhlbarg of Bowman and Brooke in Los Angeles, California and by Mr. Brian Gabel of the Yamaha Motor Corporation, U.S.A. Legal Department.

Ron Lieback
Ron Lieback
One of the few moto journalists based on the East Coast, Ron Lieback joined the motorcycle industry as a freelancer in 2007, and is currently Online Editor at Ultimate Motorcycling. He is also the author of "365 to Vision: Modern Writer's Guide (How to Produce More Quality Writing in Less Time).

2021 MV Agusta Dragster RR SCS RC First Look (9 Fast Facts)

The 2021 MV Agusta Dragster RR SCS RC is the new flagship of the urban-brawling Dragster lineup. The RC stands for Reparto Corse, and...

2022 Triumph Bonneville T100 First Look (9 Fast Facts)

The Triumph Bonneville T100 gets a more powerful and higher-revving motor for 2022,  along with a lighter chassis and upgraded suspension as the British...

2022 Triumph Street Twin First Look (7 Fast Facts)

The best-selling Triumph Street Twin is back with motor changes to meet Euro 5 standards, upgraded styling, and a classy new variant. Let’s take...

2021 Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250: 150 HP ADV [17 Fast Facts]

Harley-Davidson officially unveiled Monday its all-new adventure touring motorcycles, the 2021 Pan America 1250 and Pan America 1250 Special. The Motor Company released all the...

Story of Warner Riley’s 200+ MPH Run Aboard a Sportster 50 Years Ago!

50 years ago Warner Riley began working toward having the World’s Fastest Conventional Motorcycle. With help from S&S Cycle in Wisconsin, topping 200 mph...

Tourmaster Transition Jacket Review: Back to the Start

After getting up to a fifth edition, Tourmaster has started over with the new Transition jacket. Lacking a number—though there is a V6 on...